Come and get it! Where to order Thanksgiving pies

This beauty is an apple crumb pie from Main Street, Kingston

This beauty is an apple crumb pie from Main Street, Kingston

Got Pie?

Not everyone can make time to bake at Thanksgiving. Or maybe you’re just not inclined that way. No problem, local farm markets and bakeshops have got you covered, so here are a few options in our area. Not everyone I queried has responded, so if I get more information I’ll add it.


Brick Farm Market

(609) 466-6500

We are offering apple pie, for which we use local apples $16
Chocolate pecan pie $18
Sweet potato pie, the sweet potatoes are from a farm in south jersey $16
Pumpkin pie $16

Order by November 20, although they plan to have some pies for sale in the Market

The deadline for pick up is the Wednesday, the day before Thanksgiving (we are closed on Thanksgiving).

Gingered PeachThe Gingered Peach
(609) 896-5848

This Lawrenceville Bakery has posted their Thanksgiving Dessert menu (at left, click to enlarge) on their Facebook page. It doesn’t mention an ordering deadline, but I wouldn’t wait until the last minute – they’re very popular!


Griggstown Farm

(908) 359-5218

Prices of all pies are $14.

Apple Crumb with Walnuts and Oats
Apple with Blueberries
Blackberry Pear
Peach with Raspberries and Blueberries
Strawberry Rhubarb with Walnuts Oats
Sweet Potato

Order by: The deadline to order a BAKED pie is Saturday, November 21. They may pick up a non-baked frozen pie anytime.  Dates of pick-up are November 23-25 (closed Thanksgiving).

For further detail, you may visit our website at

LiLLiPiES Bake-To-Order Bakery

(609) 240-7738
1225 State Road 206 Suite 16 Princeton, NJ  08540

NJ Apple-Streusel, Apple-Cranberry-Streusel, Chocolate Chess w/fleur de sel, Bourbon-Pecan, Classic Pumpkin Custard.  For those who would like to bake their own pie, but are just a bit pressed for time, we’ll also offer a “bake-your-own pie kit”, which includes an all-butter pie crust (rolled out and crimped), streusel topping, and instructions to bake your own apple pie.

$25 for $9″ pies,
$30/doz LiLLiPiES single-serving pies
$15/doz LiLLiPiES bite-sized pies
$10: “Bake-Your-Own” kit

Order by: November 12th or until all of our pick-up time slots fill up.

Customers should call or email to reserve one of these dates/times for pick-up of their pie(s):

Mon, Nov 23, 10-12 noon
Mon, Nov 23, 6-7pm
Tues, Nov 24, 10-12 noon
Tues, Nov 24, 6-7pm
Wed, Nov 25, 10-12 noon

Lucy’s Kitchen & Market

(609) 924-6881

We make our pies on premise from scratch! Local apples even!

Our baker stays thru the night and finishes the pies early Wednesday morning!!!

Pumpkin Pie $16.95, Apple Pie  $19.95, Chocolate Pecan Bourbon $21.95

(We also sell Pumpkin Bread, Pumpkin Cookies and Cranberry nut loaf, and pumpkin cheesecake.)

Order by: November  22, 2015 (Sunday)   We always have a few pies extra in the store.

Pickup: We are open on Wednesday till 5:00 when all orders can be picked up.  We are closed on Thanksgiving.

Courtesy Terhune Orchards

Courtesy Terhune Orchards

Terhune Orchards

(609) 924-2310

Visit Terhune’s Pie Sampling Weekend November 14 & 15, 9:00am-5:00pm.

Types of pies offered: Apple, Apple Streusel,  Apple Cranberry, Apple Walnut, Apple No-Sugar, Blueberry, Blueberry No-Sugar, Cherry, Cherry No-Sugar, Coconut Custard, Lemon Blueberry, Peach, Peach No-Sugar, Peach Melba, Pecan, Pumpkin, Strawberry Rhubarb, Sweet Potato, and Very Berry pies

Pies are $12.50, $13.99 and $15.99

Ordering deadline: Need to know the day before picking up

Order Pickup: Up until 12 noon on Thanksgiving day.

Whole Earth Center

(609) 924-7429

Pies: Traditional and vegan pecan, traditional and vegan pumpkin, vegan apple

traditional and vegan pecan – 23.00
traditional and vegan pumpkin – 23.00
vegan apple – 26.00

Order by: Sunday 11/22

Pickup: Wednesday 11/25 (closed Thanksgiving).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s